In John 3:1–10, Mike Riccardi uses Jesus’ conversation with Nicodemus to explain why religious credentials and outward change cannot bring anyone into God’s kingdom. Jesus says we must be born again, a work only God can do.
You Must Be Born Again:
The Necessity of the New Birth
John 3:1–10
Introduction
What makes someone a Christian? There’s a lot of confusion over the answer to that question—even within the church. What makes someone a Christian? At the most fundamental level, what does it mean to be a follower of Christ?
Some of you have heard me say this before, but: Many people would say that what makes someone a Christian is family tradition or heredity. They were born into a Christian family. A person of Scottish descent is born “Scottish,” so if your parents and grandparents were Christians, well then you’re born “Christian.” Others would say that it’s good manners, politeness, and a pleasant attitude that make you a Christian: Someone who says “Please” and “Thank You,” “Yes sir,” and “No ma’am,” someone who looks you in the eye and smiles when they talk to you—that’s a Christian. Others would say that being a Christian means you fight for the betterment of society; Christians fight poverty, feed the hungry, and devote themselves to working for social justice. Still others identify Christianity with a political platform. If you’re for limited government and economic conservativism and traditional sexual ethics, well then you’re a Christian.
Some people are little bit more “religious.” They say that a Christian is someone who lives a moral life—someone who doesn’t cheat on their spouse or cheat on their taxes; someone who doesn’t abuse alcohol or use drugs, someone who doesn’t use foul language and isn’t violent. Others would say you’re a Christian if you perform your religious duties: read your Bible, pray to Jesus, attend church, go to Bible study, and find a place to serve. You’re a Christian if you fear the Lord’s coming judgment upon sinners, and sincerely feel bad about the sins you commit. Still others would say that what makes someone a Christian is praying the sinner’s prayer; or coming forward at the end of a church service, answering an altar call; or having a crisis experience and calling out to God for help; or making a resolved decision or commitment to call yourself a Christian.
But I am here to tell you this morning that none of those things makes a person a Christian. Now, it’s true that Christians mourn over their sin. It’s true that Christians read Scripture, pray, and are faithful, participating members of a local church. It’s true that Christians are faithful to their spouses, and don’t give themselves to drunkenness, and discipline their tongues. Christians do live changed lives. But not one of those things makes them a Christian. Christianity is not so natural of a religion that you can be a Christian if you clean up your life and your language, alter your weekend calendar, and learn when and how to say few memorized phrases that make you sound spiritual.
Man’s problem isn’t that our thinking, or our speech, or our behavior, or our politics just need to be refined a little here and there. No, something is so fundamentally wrong with us—with all of us—that in John chapter 3, Jesus says that if any of us is to have any hope of seeing the kingdom of God, we must be born all over again. The call of the Gospel—the call of conversion to Christianity—is not behavior modification. Sin has so infected and corrupted mankind that, if we are to be saved, nothing less is required of us than the wholesale renovation of our soul. One of my favorite quotes from the Prince of Preachers, Charles Spurgeon, is: “The Scripture does not say, ‘Ye must be improved,’ but ‘Ye must be born again.’”
What makes a person a Christian—what truly distinguishes a genuine believer in Jesus from those who are unsaved—is the new birth. It is regeneration: the spiritual recreation of one dead in sin; the divine impartation of spiritual life into the soul of the dead sinner. “We too all formerly lived in the lusts of our flesh, indulging the desires of the flesh and of the mind, and were by nature children of wrath, even as the rest. But God, being rich in mercy, because of His great love with which He loved us, even when we were dead in our transgressions, made us alive together with Christ.”
In the exercise of His sovereign pleasure, God issues an effectual call in the heart of the elect. He powerfully summons the sinner out of his spiritual death and blindness and—by virtue of the power that His Word has to create the realities it calls for—He imparts new spiritual life. He gives the sinner a new heart. He gives him eyes to see and ears to hear. He effectually calls His people “out of darkness” and “into His marvelous light,” 1 Peter 2:9. Thus being made alive, He sovereignly grants them the gift of saving faith, by which they lay hold of Christ and the salvation He purchased for them. This is the divine miracle of the new birth.
It is that spiritual heart surgery performed by Almighty God, wherein He removes your sinful heart of stone and totally transforms you, from the inside out, so that your mind, your heart, and your will are entirely renewed. He gives you a new heart and puts a new spirit within you. Your spiritual eyes, once blind to the glory of Christ, are opened to behold the ugliness of sin and the beauty of holiness as it is comprehended in Jesus. The sin that once tasted sweet now brings nothing but bitterness. And the righteousness and the virtue you once had no taste for is now what you hunger and thirst after. You see, the Christian is the one who has been born again—made an entirely new creation—from the inside out.
This is what it means to be a Christian. This is how anyone who is a Christian becomes a Christian. No external reformation, no moral refinement, no schedule alteration, no counterfeit-able changes around the periphery of your soul can accomplish what is necessary. If you, dear GraceLifer, are ever to see the kingdom of heaven—you must be born again.
And as I said, it’s in our text this morning in John chapter 3 that the Lord Jesus Himself, as the Great Prophet of our salvation reveals this truth to a most notable inquirer. Chapter 2 comes to a close with the Apostle John telling us that there is a kind of “believing” that Jesus doesn’t believe in. Verse 23 says, “Now when He was in Jerusalem at the Passover, during the feast, many believed in His name, observing His signs which He was doing. But Jesus, on His part, was not entrusting Himself to them, for He knew all men, and because He did not need anyone to testify concerning man, for He Himself knew what was in man.” Because Jesus knew all men, and because He knew what was in man, He didn’t trust anything about these people who professed to believe in His name. They believed in Him, in some sense, but He didn’t believe in them. John MacArthur would always say, “He had no faith in their faith.”
Why not? Because, most fundamentally, their faith was grounded upon and driven by signs. Sign-driven faith comes to Jesus for the wine, for the bread, for the miracle. But a sign is not designed to be looked to, as an object of our faith. A sign is designed to be looked through, as a means to our faith in the glorious person and work of Christ Himself, who saves you from sin. We said last week: You’re supposed to look beyond the wine at the wedding of Cana through to the One who is Himself the wine that makes the heart of man glad for eternity. You’re supposed to look beyond the bread that fed 5,000 people lunch through to the One who is Himself the bread of life from heaven that satisfies the soul. Sign-driven faith wants bread for lunch and wine for drink. True and saving faith wants the bread of life and the fountain of living waters as a Savior from sin, and as an all-satisfying God to worship.
And so it is no accident that chapter 2 closes with the statement, “He did not need anyone to testify concerning man, for He Himself knew what was in man,” and then chapter 3 opens by saying, “Now there was a man of the Pharisees, named Nicodemus, a ruler of the Jews; [and] this man came to Jesus by night and said to Him, ‘Rabbi, we know that You have come from God as a teacher; for no one can do these signs that You do unless God is with him.’” Chapter 2 says Jesus knows the heart of man, and doesn’t trust the faith of those who believe merely on the basis of signs. Chapter 3 introduces us to a man who believes true things about Jesus on the basis of signs. And he sounds great: Nicodemus calls Jesus a Rabbi; he says it’s evident He’s a teacher of divine truth sent from God; and He says God is with Him.
If Jesus were a contemporary evangelical senior pastor, He’d have already hired Nicodemus as an associate pastor! But what does He say? Verse 3: “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one is born again he cannot see the kingdom of God.” “You think you can see these miracles, Nicodemus? The spiritual sight you need to look through the signs and not merely to the signs—you can’t have that kind of sight unless you’re born all over again!”
Let’s read the rest of the passage. Verse 4: Nicodemus replies, “‘How can a man be born when he is old? He cannot enter a second time into his mother’s womb and be born, can he?’ Jesus answered, ‘Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one is born of water and the Spirit he cannot enter into the kingdom of God. That which is born of the flesh is flesh, and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit. Do not be amazed that I said to you, “You must be born again.” The wind blows where it wishes, and you hear the sound of it, but do not know where it comes from and where it is going; so is everyone who is born of the Spirit.’ Nicodemus said to Him, ‘How can these things be?’ Jesus answered and said to him, ‘Are you the teacher of Israel and do not understand these things?’”
In this remarkable conversation between Jesus and Nicodemus, our Lord speaks of both the necessity and the nature of the new birth. This morning, we’re going to devote our time to understanding Christ’s teaching on the necessity of the new birth. There is no way anyone, at any time, in any place, from any background, in any circumstance, at all will enter the kingdom of heaven, except by the supernatural, transforming work of God called the new birth. It is absolutely necessary.
That is going to be our focus for this morning. And in this interaction with Nicodemus, we see the necessity of the new birth in three ways. It is adeptly illustrated; it is emphatically asserted; and it is insightfully explained.
I. Adeptly Illustrated (vv. 1–2, 9–10)
In the first place, consider the necessity of the new birth adeptly illustrated. Who is it that the Lord Jesus tells he must be born again? John says, “Now there was a man of the Pharisees.”
Pharisaism began as a sect of Judaism that was wholly devoted to the pure teaching of Scripture. In fact, the word Pharisee derives from the Hebrew term parash, which means “to separate.” So, “Pharisee” originally meant a “separated one.” The Pharisees were the descendants of the Hasidim—that group of pious Jews in the second century BC who successfully opposed the oppressive Seleucid ruler, Antiochus Epiphanes. Antiochus attempted to stamp out the Jewish faith all together, principally by syncretizing it with Greek religion. He wanted to water down Judaism into some hybrid with Greek paganism, and it was the ancestors of the Pharisees that withstood those attacks and preserved biblical religion.
And that strong devotion to the standard of God’s law continued to mark them during the days of Jesus. The Herodians had sold themselves out to politics. The Sadducees were the religious liberals who only accepted the first five books of the Old Testament, and who denied its supernatural aspects, like the existence of angels and the resurrection of the body. But the Pharisees rejected those kinds of perversions and insisted that the whole of Scripture was to be the rule of life for the people of God. One commentator says, “the name basically means those who have separated themselves from all loose religious practices and live in strict accordance with the law. … the Pharisees were the party of strict orthodoxy” (Morris, 122n31). And so Paul in Acts 26:5 said that he “lived as a Pharisee according to the strictest sect of our religion.”
The Pharisees’ problem, of course, was that, by the first century, they became stricter than the Scriptures themselves. They allowed their religious devotion to supersede biblical authority, and they elevated the oral traditions of their elders to a status that was virtually equal to the Word of God. Maybe they reasoned that if the people obeyed their traditions, they’d never come close to disobeying the Scripture. But as always happens, they began “teaching as doctrines the precepts of men” (Matt 15:9). Their supposéd love for pure religion degenerated into legalistic externalism. And it’s for that kind of hypocrisy—that cleans the outside of the cup while leaving the inside unwashed—that our Lord rebukes them so harshly during His ministry.
But here at the outset of the Lord’s ministry, to be Pharisee was to be a member of the elite social class in Israel. They were at the top of the social food chain, because they were the gatekeepers of religious life. If you met the standards of the Pharisees, you were in the in-crowd. They devoted themselves to the study of the Law, and the common people highly respected them as the religious doctors—the professors and scholars, who told us what the Word of God really meant, over and against those who would pervert it, and who were thought to maintain a standard of holiness that would have awed the common people.
But not only was Nicodemus a man of the Pharisees. John goes on to call him, “a ruler of the Jews.” He was a member of the Sanhedrin, the governing council in Israel, which, though it was subject to the civil authority of the occupying Roman government, nevertheless presided over religious matters. Jewish tradition regarded the concept of the Sanhedrin to have descended from the seventy elders of Israel whom God raised up to assist Moses with the government of the people in Numbers chapter 11. Like those elders, the Sanhedrin consisted of seventy members, made up of influential priestly families, elders of the tribes, and the scribes who were experts in the law (MacArthur, 101), with the High Priest of Israel serving as the president of the Council. As we see in the case of Jesus in Matthew 26, and then also with the Apostles in Acts chapter 4 and 5, the Sanhedrin had the authority both to arrest and put people on trial on religious grounds (cf. MacArthur, 101). So, not only was Nicodemus a member of the most respected religious sect; he was also a member of the ruling Council.
And beyond even that, in verse 10, Jesus calls him “the teacher of Israel.” It’s one thing to be a teacher of Israel—a rabbi, someone respected by the people enough to provide for them an accurate understanding of the Word of God. It is another thing to be the teacher of Israel. The article is emphatic here. One commentator says it “suggests he was a recognized master, an established religious authority,” akin to calling him, “Reverend Professor Doctor” (Carson, 198). And it is still another thing to be the teacher of Israel and a Pharisee and a member of the Sanhedrin! John Gill paraphrased it: “that master, doctor, or teacher; that famous, and most excellent one, who was talked of all over Jerusalem and Judea, as a surpassing one.” Nicodemus was the kind of man that families would have seen walking down the street, and parents would say to their kids, “Do you see that man, there? That is a great man in Israel” (cf. Martin).
“This man,” verse 2 says, “came to Jesus by night.” And there are all sorts of ideas for why Nicodemus came at nighttime. Many believe he waited until night out of fear or shame. Maybe he didn’t want to suggest that the Sanhedrin were favorable to Jesus. Maybe he was embarrassed that a respected teacher like himself would go to Jesus to be instructed by Him. Maybe he didn’t want the other members of the Sanhedrin to given him a hard time or remove him from his high standing. But it also could have been that Nicodemus knew that night would provide an opportunity for uninterrupted conversation, and without the stress of a listening crowd. One way or the other, the Lord Jesus receives Nicodemus, and speaks with him.
And he said to Him, “Rabbi, we know that You have come from God as a teacher; for no one can do these signs that You do unless God is with him.” Consider not only who Nicodemus is and the résumé he has; but consider what he says to Jesus. He calls Him “Rabbi,” acknowledging Him as at least his equal; as a learnéd man. This is a show of courtesy, even respect. He says, “We know that You have come from God.” “You haven’t come on your own initiative! You’re not some upstart preacher who hasn’t been sent! And you haven’t even been sent by mere men: the God of heaven has commissioned You!” And You’ve come from God “as a teacher”—as One who can unfold the true doctrine of the Law and the Prophets. For the one who was called “the teacher of Israel” to acknowledge Jesus as a God-sent teacher: this was a big deal. And the ground of all this is that Nicodemus has seen the signs Jesus performs: “Obviously, these signs are God’s own testimony to Your genuineness!”
Now, what more could you ask for? Who was it to whom Jesus will declare, “You must be born again”? This was not a harlot, plying her uncleanness. This was not a swindler or a thief or a murderer. This was not a tax collector, who betrayed his people by collecting taxes for Rome. This wasn’t a Sadducee or a Herodian, who cared little for the Law of God. Nor was it even a Pharisee of the kind that Jesus will meet, who hates Jesus, and wants to kill Jesus out of jealousy. This is a man of the most conservative religious sect in Israel, of the most respected social standing, of the ruling council, an eminent scholar, and who is dead-on accurate in what he affirms about Jesus—not only addressing Him courteously and with respect, but acknowledging that God is with Him.
And what does Jesus say in reply? He doesn’t say, “Well thank you, Nicodemus! You’re a gentleman and a scholar! I see you have great discernment!” “Game recognizes game!” No. He doesn’t even say something like He said in Mark 12:34, “You are not far from the kingdom of God.” He says, “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one is born again he cannot see the kingdom of God”!
Is this not an adept illustration of the absolute necessity of the new birth? Dear people, do you have a better résumé than Nicodemus? What religious achievements have you attained that have outshined Nicodemus’s credentials, here? Diligent obedience, steadfast religious conservatism, strict traditionalism, the highest social standing, biblical scholarship, the highest pitch of external righteousness, even doctrinal orthodoxy when it came to the person of Christ. Jesus says, “Nope, you’ve got to be born all over again!” Do you see the point? If your confidence for entering the kingdom of heaven is any of your religious achievements, or any of your inherited advantages, Nicodemus has you beat. And Jesus tells him the only thing that will suffice is the death of the man he is and the radical transformation of his new birth into someone else.
And so, dear people, from the greater to the lesser, Jesus says the same thing to each and every one of you. What is it, friends, that you might be counting on for entrance into the kingdom of God? “I prayed with my mom when I was six years old.” “I’ve been a member at Grace Church for 20, 30, 40, 50 years.” “I was baptized by John MacArthur!” “I’ve listened to every sermon on the Grace to You Website. I’ve read every note in the MacArthur Study Bible.” “I’ve graduated FOF, Grace Equip, TMU, TMS.” “I lead a ministry.” “I’m a Bible study shepherd.” “I’m ACBC certified.” “I’m a pastor.” “I’m an elder.” “I think Jesus is great! I think He’s a teacher sent from God. I believe that the miracles He does identifies Him as having God’s approval!” None of it matters. As one preacher put it, “No new birth? No heaven!” Unless you are totally, supernaturally recreated by the hand of Almighty God Himself from the inside out you will not see the kingdom of God.
II. Emphatically Asserted (vv. 3, 5)
Well, not only is the necessity of the new birth adeptly illustrated by the example of Nicodemus. It is also emphatically asserted by the Lord Himself. Number two: the necessity of the new birth emphatically asserted.
And that emphasis appears in a number of ways. First, Jesus’ response in verse 3 begins with the double amen: “Truly, truly.” It’s the Greek, “Amen, amen.” We end our prayers with the word amen in order to say, “Let it be so,” or “May it come to pass.” Fifty times in the Synoptic Gospels Jesus uses the phrase, “Truly I say to you,” in order to make a solemn pronouncement of a truth that He wants particularly to emphasize. Only in the Gospel of John do we find the double amen, “Truly, truly I say to you.” That appears twenty-five times in John’s Gospel, and it indicates a statement of profound solemnity, of inviolable authority and certain truth, and it is done for maximum emphasis.
Jesus uses it in John 5 to speak of His working inseparably with the Father, of the fact that whoever believes in Him does not come into judgment, of the fact that He will raise the dead to life by the power of His own voice. He uses it in John 6 to demand that His disciples eat His flesh and drink His blood. He uses it in John 8 to affirm that He is the Great “I AM” who was before Abraham. He uses it in John 13 to announce that one of His own disciples will betray Him to death, and then again in the same chapter to predict Peter’s denial. And here in John 3, He uses it to emphatically assert the necessity of the new birth.
And then, secondly, the necessity of the new birth is emphatically asserted by the repetition of the unequivocal statements of verses 3 and 5: “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one”—and that is the most general word you could use to mean just absolutely anybody, of any status or any background—“unless one is born again he cannot see the kingdom of God.” And Nicodemus can’t believe his ears. Verse 4: “Nicodemus said to Him, ‘How can a man be born when he is old? He cannot enter a second time into his mother’s womb and be born, can he?’” And I love this. Jesus says, “You have to be born again to see these things!” And Nicodemus says, “I don’t see it!” It’s like 1 Corinthians 2:14: a natural man cannot understand the things of the Spirit of God; and it’s as if Nicodemus says, “I don’t understand that!” Apart from regenerating grace, your mind is blinded.
And so Jesus, undeterred, simply repeats the same emphatic assertion of man’s total inability to be saved apart from regeneration: “Jesus answered, ‘Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one is born of water and the Spirit he cannot enter into the kingdom of God.” And we’re going to talk in detail next week about how this reference to “water and the Spirit” is an allusion to Ezekiel 36:25–27—that classic prophecy of the New Covenant, in which God promises to “sprinkle clean water” upon Israel, and cleanse her from her filthiness, and to “put [His] Spirit within” them and cause them to walk in His statutes. But for now, just note the emphatic repetition. Jesus doesn’t think, “Oh, Nicodemus doesn’t quite get it. How can I water this down? How can I put these cookies on the bottom shelf?” No. No reducing the truth to the lowest common denominator. Just an emphatic re-assertion of the same truth: No new birth, no kingdom!
And then, third, the necessity of the new birth is emphatically asserted by Jesus comment in verse 7: “Do not be amazed that I said to you, ‘You must be born again.’” And here Jesus uses that wonderful little Greek word dei: delta, epsilon, iota. Grammarians call it “a particle of necessity.” Its most literal sense is, “It is necessary.” And it is often used, especially in the Gospels, and especially in John’s Gospel, of those events which must happen as a result of God’s inviolable, predestined decree. You know from Ephesians 1:11 that God “works all things after the counsel of His own will.” That is, all the things that happen in time are the result of the predetermined purpose which God established before time.
And so, John 3:14 says, “As Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must the Son of Man be lifted up.” And how necessary was the crucifixion of Christ? It had to happen! The Lamb was slain before the foundation of the world, Revelation 13:8! Or John 4:4: Jesus “had to pass through Samaria.” Why? Because He had a divine appointment with the woman at the well. John 10:16: “I have other sheep, which are not of this fold; I must bring them also, and they will hear My voice; and they will become one flock with one shepherd.” Jesus is going to save every single sheep that the Father had given to Him by sovereign election. He must bring them. He will lose none of them. John 20 verse 9 says, “They did not understand the Scripture that He must rise from the dead.” Dear people: as necessary as the crucifixion, as necessary the resurrection, as necessary is the salvation of the elect, so also is the absolute necessity of the new birth for salvation. Don’t be amazed that I say it: You must be born again. The great 18th-century evangelist, George Whitefield, was famous for preaching more sermons on the new birth than just about anything else. One time, a friend asked him, “George, why do you preach so often upon the text, ‘Ye must be born again’?” Whitefield paused and thought for a moment, and then said, “Because: you must be born again!”
III. Insightfully Explained (v. 6)
Well, we have seen the necessity of the new birth adeptly illustrated in the person of Nicodemus. We have seen it emphatically asserted in the solemn pronouncements, pointed repetition, and open declaration of our Savior. We come now in the third place to the necessity of the new birth insightfully explained. Why is it that nothing less than the radical, supernatural, wholesale renovation of the soul that is the new birth is absolutely necessary to enter the kingdom of God? Because, verse 6: “That which is born of the flesh is flesh, and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit.”
The kingdom of God is a spiritual kingdom. In 1 Corinthians 15:50, Paul says that “flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God.” It is a realm that accords entirely with the Holy Spirit. But humanity, in our natural state, since our fall into sin in Genesis 3, is flesh. And “those who are according to the flesh,” Romans 8:5, “set their minds on the things of the flesh, but those who are according to the Spirit, the things of the Spirit.” Galatians 5:17 says, “The flesh sets its desire against the Spirit, and the Spirit against the flesh; for these are in opposition to one another.” There is this utter dichotomy between flesh and Spirit.
And we are born of the flesh. Because all of humankind was counted to have sinned in union with Adam, every human being inherits a corrupt, sinful nature from conception. The nature we inherit from our parents is a sinful nature. In David’s prayer of repentance in Psalm 51, he says in verse 5, “Behold, I was brought forth in iniquity, and in sin my mother conceived me.” David says he was sinful from his very conception. “There was never a time when I was and my sinfulness was not.” He says something similar in Psalm 58:3. He writes, “The wicked are estranged from the womb; those who speak lies go astray from birth.” So our corruption does not need to be stepped into. It doesn’t need to be learned. It is something that afflicts us even while we are in our mothers’ wombs, and it’s something we come out with from the very beginning of our lives at birth. And in Ephesians 2:1, the Apostle Paul tells us all who we were before Christ saved us. He says, “And you were dead in your trespasses and sins.” Not injured, not sick; dead. Though the natural man possesses physical life from the moment of his conception, from that very same moment he is utterly devoid of any spiritual life. He is a spiritual corpse. He goes on in verse 3: “We … all formerly lived in the lusts of our flesh, indulging the desires of the flesh and of the mind, and were by nature children of wrath.” Nothing at all has to happen to us to make us this way. By nature we are children of wrath. We are born in such a way that, if nothing and no one were to intervene, we would be just recipients of the wrath of God against our sin.
And what does that mean? It means we are totally depraved. The corruption of sin extends to every aspect of man’s nature. No part of any human being remains unaffected by sin. The mind, the heart, and the will of man are all totally polluted. Ephesians 4:17–18 says the mind has become futile and the understanding darkened, so that man is characterized by spiritual ignorance. First Corinthians 2:14 says the natural man “cannot understand…the things of the Spirit of God,” because “they are foolishness to him.” The heart is a heart of stone, Ezekiel 11:19—cold and unresponsive to divine truth. Though the light shines ever so brightly in the eyes of the natural man’s heart, he will always and ever refuse it, because, John 3:19, he loves darkness rather than the light. The will of the natural man is enslaved to sin, Romans 6:17. It delights in the manure pile of sin and turns in disgust from the pure streams of righteousness.
This is why Jesus tells Nicodemus that unless he is born again he cannot see the kingdom of God. It’s because man’s natural state since the fall is a state of spiritual blindness. Paul says in 2 Corinthians 4:4: “The god of this world has blinded the minds of the unbelieving so that they might not see the light of the gospel of the glory of Christ, who is the image of God.” That is the miserable nature of spiritual death! of total depravity: people look upon glory—the most delightful, beautiful thing imaginable in the face of Jesus Christ, a willing Savior—and they see nothing of value. As I say: they delight in the manure pile and are disgusted by the treasure chest of loveliness in Christ. The heart is so disordered by sin that it refuses what is most precious because it is blind to its value, and prefers what is most heinous because it is blind to its detriment. This is who we are.
You say, “How is that ever going to change? The heart is hard. Our loves are disordered. We’re corrupt from the inside out.” “Well, you say, we have to decide to repent and believe in Christ.” But that’s the problem: that is precisely what the natural, fleshly man is unable to do. Saving faith consists in the mind’s knowledge of the facts of the Gospel, the heart’s glad embrace of those facts, and the will’s casting the entire soul upon Christ—trusting Him and entrusting oneself to Him, relying utterly upon Him alone for the forgiveness of sins and a record of righteousness which meets the demands of God’s holiness. In other words, saving faith requires the proper working of the human soul in all its faculties: the mind, the heart, and the will. But if the mind, heart, and will of the natural man is darkened, hardened, and enslaved, so that it is truly morally incapable of working properly, then it is impossible for the natural man to exercise saving faith.
Said another way: “That which is born of the flesh is flesh, and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit.” We who are born of the flesh can never change ourselves into anything other than flesh. One commentator captured it well when he said, “Sinful human nature produces only sinful human nature” (Hendriksen). Another said, “There is no evolution from flesh to Spirit” (Morris, 194). Job asks, in chapter 14 verse 4: “Who can make the clean out of the unclean? No one!” You can’t bring cleanness from uncleanness. You have to be cleansed by a power outside of yourself. Paul says in 1 Corinthians 2:14 that the natural man cannot understand the things of the Spirit. It’s impossible. Dead men do not decide to stop being dead. They don’t have the capacity. Their only hope for life resides entirely outside of them.
So do you see how miserable is the nature of man’s hopeless condition in sin? The natural man cannot spontaneously decide to believe the Gospel. He must become a supernatural, spiritual man before he can receive the Gospel in faith. And so Jesus will say in John 6:44, “No one can come to Me unless the Father who sent Me draws him.” And then in John 6:65: “No one can come to Me unless it has been granted him from the Father.” We are so helpless that we can’t even get to the remedy (cf. Martin).
The one thing we need most is entirely outside our power to perform. Until man’s nature is changed in regeneration, he is nothing but flesh. And flesh can only produce flesh. The only way any spiritual life is possible is if man’s nature is changed and his will is freed and his heart is renewed. He has to be born of the Spirit, and so be changed from flesh to spirit, from death to life, from darkness to light. And so what does God do? Second Corinthians 4:6: He shines “in our hearts to give the Light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Christ.” He births the light of eternal spiritual life where there was only death and darkness. He cures spiritual blindness with the light of the glory of Jesus. O, can you see how absolutely necessary is the new birth?
Conclusion
And not just “necessary” in the abstract, dear people. Not just theoretically necessary for “mankind,” or “the sinner,” in general. Necessary for you. You must be born again! And you say, “Mike, you’ve just finished telling us that it’s impossible for us to do anything to induce this new birth in ourselves. We can’t change from flesh to spirit; we can’t go from natural to supernatural. So how can you call us to be born again, when it lies entirely outside our power?”
Dear sinner: I’ve presented the Bible’s teaching to you in this way precisely in order to strip away from you every rival source of confidence for your spiritual standing before God except Christ alone. Because, as I’ve said, too many of you will sit here—for 20, 30, 40, 50 years—and hear the true Gospel of justification by faith alone, apart from any of your works and for the call to true discipleship in following Christ in holiness. And you will still flatter yourselves that you’re truly in Christ because of some external duties you perform. Whether it’s Bible reading, church membership, some kind of service, even just accumulation of knowledge: “I’m saved because I know the truth.” Dear friends, Nicodemus knew the truth, and he had a better résumé than you, and Jesus told him he had to be born all over again!
You say, “So what do I do? I can’t reform my life. I can’t even betake myself to the remedy. What do I do?” You cry out in humble prayer to a sovereign God to have mercy on your soul—to open your eyes to the ugliness and filthiness of sin; to grant you true and genuine repentance from sin; freedom from the idols you cherish so fondly; an authentic, from-the-bones hatred for sin. And you ask Him to open your eyes to the loveliness of Jesus—to grant you true, genuine, whole-souled faith in Him; that you would see in Him a supremacy over every rival source of righteousness, and every rival source of pleasure.
Now if you’re saying, “Mike, you spoke so much about why we need to be born again. But I’d like to understand better about what precisely the new birth is. What happens in regeneration?” then join us next week, as we turn from the necessity of the new birth to the nature of the new birth.